Cognitive shuffling

Cognitive shuffling word list

A cognitive shuffling word list is a set of concrete, emotionally neutral things that are easy to picture and unrelated to one another. Here are 280 of them in 28 groups — the words Sheeps’ Radio mode reads — along with the one rule that makes a list work: never put two words from the same group next to each other.

5 min readBy SheepsHow we write these pages

What makes a good cognitive shuffling word?

A word that produces an image straight away and then lets it go. In practice that means:

  • Concrete. A thing you could see or hold — a ladle, not a plan. Cognitive shuffling works on images, and abstract words produce thoughts instead.
  • Calm. Nothing that raises the pulse, even pleasantly. A kite, not a rollercoaster.
  • Mildly pleasant. Neither bleak nor thrilling.
  • Short. Mostly one to three syllables. Eight seconds after “moth” feels different from eight seconds after “refrigerator”.
  • Picturable on its own. Not the stuff a scene is made of — room, air, floor, wall — which gives the mind nothing to hold.
  • Impersonal. No names, no places you have been, nothing with a memory attached.

Every word below meets those tests, and every one has been through the same automated safety check as Sheeps’ stories, so none of them is something you hear at two in the morning and have to think about.

How do you use a word list?

Reading a list in bed by the light of a phone defeats the purpose, so a list is best used in one of three ways:

  1. Have it read to you. One word, a pause of about eight seconds, the next word — the rhythm used in the research on the technique. You picture each thing until the next one arrives. This is what the structured form, serial diverse imagining, is.
  2. Record it yourself. Read a sequence slowly into a voice memo, leaving a long pause after each word, and play it back in the dark.
  3. Borrow the groups. Before bed, pick a few groups from the list below. In bed, move between them — a pear, a heron, a lantern, a scarf — without going through any one group in order.

If you would rather generate your own words, the seed-word method needs no list at all: think of a neutral word such as bedtime, and for each letter picture a few unrelated things that start with it. It is described step by step in the cognitive shuffling guide.

Sheeps is cognitive shuffling as a story: harmless, unrelated scenes, read to you, ending in silence.

Download on the App Store

The one rule: keep neighbours apart

Two words from the same group side by side — ship, boat, ferry — hand the mind something to connect, and connecting things is the one activity the technique exists to prevent. Three boats in a row is no longer a shuffle; it is the start of a harbour.

Sheeps’ Radio keeps any two words from the same group at least three places apart, and the sequence below follows the same rule. If you make your own, the groups are there to help you do the same.

A ready-made sequence

40 words, in an order where no group repeats within three places. Read them slowly, or record them with a long pause after each.

  1. biscuit
  2. firefly
  3. barrel
  4. chisel
  5. kayak
  6. scooter
  7. lemonade
  8. drum
  9. envelope
  10. chestnut
  11. armchair
  12. teddy
  13. typewriter
  14. cider
  15. pea
  16. puppet
  17. carafe
  18. oak
  19. carriage
  20. colander
  21. taper
  22. sherbet
  23. frost
  24. velvet
  25. spatula
  26. cello
  27. hoop
  28. tractor
  29. hail
  30. rake
  31. mortar
  32. stamp
  33. jar
  34. urchin
  35. dragonfly
  36. donkey
  37. bookcase
  38. clam
  39. ferry
  40. waistcoat

All 280 words, in 28 groups

The groups exist to keep neighbours apart, not to be read through. Take one word from here and the next from somewhere else entirely.

Fruit
  • apple
  • banana
  • plum
  • cherry
  • fig
  • peach
  • lemon
  • pear
  • grape
  • apricot
Vegetables
  • carrot
  • turnip
  • pumpkin
  • cabbage
  • onion
  • radish
  • bean
  • pea
  • leek
  • celery
Trees
  • oak
  • willow
  • birch
  • pine
  • maple
  • elm
  • cedar
  • walnut
  • chestnut
  • poplar
Flowers
  • tulip
  • daisy
  • poppy
  • iris
  • lily
  • lavender
  • clover
  • thistle
  • violet
  • peony
Birds
  • pigeon
  • sparrow
  • heron
  • magpie
  • owl
  • swan
  • robin
  • finch
  • gull
  • crane
Insects
  • moth
  • beetle
  • cricket
  • ladybird
  • dragonfly
  • bee
  • ant
  • grasshopper
  • firefly
  • mayfly
Animals
  • otter
  • hare
  • badger
  • deer
  • fox
  • mole
  • squirrel
  • hedgehog
  • donkey
  • goat
By the shore
  • cockle
  • urchin
  • kelp
  • coral
  • clam
  • oyster
  • seaweed
  • starfish
  • barnacle
  • mussel
Boats
  • barge
  • ferry
  • canoe
  • raft
  • dinghy
  • tugboat
  • sailboat
  • kayak
  • gondola
  • trawler
Ways to travel
  • bicycle
  • tram
  • wagon
  • tractor
  • carriage
  • sledge
  • scooter
  • caravan
  • trolley
  • rickshaw
Tools
  • hammer
  • chisel
  • pliers
  • wrench
  • trowel
  • shovel
  • rake
  • auger
  • ladder
  • clamp
In the kitchen
  • ladle
  • whisk
  • kettle
  • colander
  • saucepan
  • skillet
  • grater
  • spatula
  • teapot
  • mortar
On the table
  • saucer
  • tureen
  • goblet
  • platter
  • decanter
  • pitcher
  • tumbler
  • napkin
  • coaster
  • carafe
Furniture
  • stool
  • dresser
  • wardrobe
  • armchair
  • bookcase
  • bench
  • ottoman
  • cabinet
  • sideboard
  • hammock
Fabrics
  • wool
  • linen
  • velvet
  • corduroy
  • flannel
  • tweed
  • silk
  • canvas
  • felt
  • gauze
Clothes
  • mitten
  • scarf
  • apron
  • cardigan
  • slipper
  • raincoat
  • waistcoat
  • bonnet
  • poncho
  • overall
Instruments
  • cello
  • oboe
  • harp
  • banjo
  • accordion
  • tambourine
  • flute
  • drum
  • ukulele
  • xylophone
Curious machines
  • compass
  • typewriter
  • telescope
  • gramophone
  • barometer
  • metronome
  • radio
  • television
  • sundial
  • abacus
Things that hold things
  • basket
  • bucket
  • satchel
  • crate
  • jar
  • tin
  • barrel
  • hamper
  • canister
  • bag
On the desk
  • envelope
  • postcard
  • notebook
  • pencil
  • ribbon
  • stamp
  • ledger
  • blotter
  • inkwell
  • folder
Buildings
  • lighthouse
  • windmill
  • greenhouse
  • chapel
  • barn
  • cottage
  • bakery
  • bandstand
  • boathouse
  • granary
Landscapes
  • meadow
  • dune
  • orchard
  • hedgerow
  • marsh
  • glacier
  • valley
  • moor
  • thicket
  • pasture
Weather
  • frost
  • drizzle
  • mist
  • snowflake
  • dew
  • hail
  • rainbow
  • breeze
  • sleet
  • fog
Stones
  • pebble
  • flint
  • quartz
  • marble
  • slate
  • granite
  • amber
  • chalk
  • obsidian
  • geode
Lights
  • candle
  • lantern
  • chandelier
  • lampshade
  • beacon
  • sparkler
  • taper
  • filament
  • moonlight
  • starlight
Toys
  • kite
  • spinning top
  • yo-yo
  • puppet
  • rocking horse
  • jigsaw
  • teddy
  • whistle
  • hoop
  • domino
Food
  • bread
  • honey
  • porridge
  • biscuit
  • marmalade
  • dumpling
  • custard
  • pancake
  • waffle
  • scone
Drinks
  • cocoa
  • cider
  • lemonade
  • buttermilk
  • tea
  • sherbet
  • broth
  • nectar
  • syrup
  • milk

Which words should you leave out?

  • Anything with your own story in it. Your street, a friend’s name, the dish your grandmother made. Personal significance pulls the mind back into thinking.
  • Anything that starts a chain. Email, invoice, dentist, tomorrow — words that point at something still to be done.
  • Anything unsettling, however mildly. If a word brings up something you would rather not think about, drop it and move on.
  • Abstract words. Freedom, patience, strategy. There is nothing to picture, so the mind reaches for reasons instead.
  • Words you cannot picture quickly. If an image does not arrive, skip it. The list is not a test.

If you cannot picture things at all, the same list still works as something for attention to rest on: see cognitive shuffling with aphantasia.

Sources

  1. Beaudoin, Digdon, O’Neill & Rachor (2016) — Serial diverse imagining task: a new remedy for bedtime complaints of worrying and other sleep-disruptive mental activity. Poster abstract, SLEEP 2016
  2. Beaudoin (2014) — A design-based approach to sleep-onset and insomnia: super-somnolent mentation, the cognitive shuffle and serial diverse imagining
  3. mySleepButton — The cognitive shuffle: do-it-yourself instructions